Psychological safety is widely recognized as essential to effective learning in health professions education, yet much of the literature defines it by its absence—focusing on mistreatment rather than exploring learners’ own conceptions of what psychological safety is. In this talk, I present findings from a study exploring how medical students experience psychological safety within a peer mentorship learning context. Students described safety as “not feeling judged,” which allowed them to be more present, take learning risks, and build authentic relationships. I propose reframing psychological safety as educational safety—a relational construct that can help us build learning environments that foster trust, mentorship, vulnerability, and support.